top of page

Comparing Moderate and Vigorous Exercise for Longevity

woman exercising on assault bike

In the world of fitness, the age-old adage "no pain, no gain" has long been the mantra. But is pushing your body to the brink really the key to a worthwhile workout? Let's explore a more nuanced perspective on exercise intensity and its impact on mortality rates.

Breaking the Mold: Rethinking Exercise Intensity

Recent research led by Lee and colleagues delves into the relationship between exercise intensity and mortality rates. Drawing from extensive data gathered in the Nurses’ Health Study and Health Professionals Follow-up Study, the study sheds light on the effects of both moderate and vigorous-intensity exercise on longevity.

Understanding Exercise Intensity: More Than Just Sweat

Measuring exercise intensity in METs (Metabolic Equivalent of Task), the study distinguishes between moderate (less than 6 METs) and vigorous (6 METs or more) activities. From brisk walking to intense circuit training, each activity falls into a specific category, and the study aims to decipher their impact on overall mortality.

Vigorous vs. Moderate: The Verdict on Longevity

The study reveals intriguing insights into the benefits of both exercise intensities. Vigorous-intensity exercise, performed for 75–144 minutes per week, significantly reduces all-cause mortality by 19%, cardiovascular disease (CVD) mortality by 31%, and non-CVD mortality by 15%. On the other hand, moderate-intensity exercise, ranging from 150–299 minutes per week, boasts continuous benefits, resulting in a 19% to 25% lower risk of all-cause, CVD, and non-CVD mortality.

Vigorous-intensity exercise for 150–299 minutes per week and moderate-intensity exercise for 300–599 minutes per week showcase marginal mortality reductions. However, the study emphasizes that additional benefits beyond mortality, such as strength and muscle mass improvements, depend on individual goals.

Applying the Findings: Practical Recommendations for a Healthier You

Drawing practical insights from the study, here are actionable recommendations:

  1. Optimize Limited Time: If time is scarce, prioritize vigorous-intensity exercise, incorporating strategies like high-intensity interval training or rest-reducing resistance training.

  2. Moderation with Available Time: For those with more time, striking a balance between moderate and vigorous intensity exercises is key. Avoiding extremes ensures both benefits and minimizes the risk of injury or overtraining.

  3. Embrace Exercise: Regardless of intensity, more exercise generally equates to better health. Integrating physical activity into daily life, enjoying a variety of activities, and finding what suits your preferences contribute to a healthier lifestyle.


bottom of page